Often, they adapt the works they offer to meet particular conditions.
Centuries-old works written for instruments that have become obsolete may be adapted for ones currently in use.
Such an approach meant presenting music in the forms with which musicians and audiences of the present were familiar; when in 1829 Felix Mendelssohn revived J. Bach's Retrospective editions followed the same practice: this meant that realized continuos might be provided; lyrics would be syllabified and underlaid with a precision lacking in many earlier sources; and accidentals would be handled in accordance with modern conventions.
Moreover, nineteenth-century notation regulated many more aspects of music than had the notations of earlier centuries, and since prospective users were accustomed to the guidance provided by nineteenth-century texts, editors might supply performance suggestions that nineteenth-century musicians would expect but that texts predating the late eighteenth century might not provide.
When Foucault penned his , he was thinking about literary works, but his insight is equally valid for any of the creative arts for which editions are prepared—literature, drama, or music.
The implications of Foucault's observation—and its corollary—are especially intriguing for music, where two sorts of editions, intended for different musical communities, reflect two different concepts of the musical work and two different views of the functions of the musical text.
Restated in less provocative form, Foucault's observation reminds us that what an editor does—the sort of edition that he sets out to produce, the sorts of decisions that he makes at each stage along the way, the uses that he thinks his edition will serve—is dependent upon what he believes a work to be.
And Foucault's observation has a corollary: different ideas of what a work is generate different sorts of editions.
Historical musicology, effectively a species of , was being born, and many of the practitioners of this new discipline came to see musicological editions less as means to performance than as texts of record.
For such musicologists, the introduction of editorial performing suggestions seemed "unscientific," and by the end of the nineteenth century there had arisen a demand for editions that not only made the music of the past available but that presented that music in the forms in which it had originally been inscribed and disseminated.
Comments Music Performance Essay
Analysing Performance and Performing Analysis - UNAM
Keyboard Music', Carl Schachter, 'Chopin's Prelude in D major, Op. 28, No. 5 Analysis and Performance', and Elizabeth West Marvin, 'Intrinsic Motivation The Relation of Analysis to Performance in Undergraduate Music Theory Instruction', all in Journal of Music Theory Pedagogy, 8 1994, 3-26, 27-46, and 47-57 respectively.…
Music Essay Examples Kibin
Stuck on your essay? Browse essays about Music and find inspiration. Learn by example and become a better writer with Kibin’s suite of essay help services.…
A List Of 10 Most Interesting Music Thesis Topics
Top 10 music thesis topics. Any music lover would enjoy the opportunity to write about their favor part of music. This can be anything from writing about your favorite musical artist to schemes and scams related to unreleased music content that was somehow leaked to the general public.…
Overcoming Performance Anxiety in Music, Acting. -
Commonly called “stage fright,” performance anxiety is the fear of doing something in front of a group of people. The experts at WebMD offer strategies for feeling comfortable ''on stage.''…
FREE Jazz Band Concert Review Essay - ExampleEssays
UF Jazz Band Concert Review Before taking History of Jazz, I personally was not a fan of jazz concerts or jazz music overall. Because of this course, I attended my first jazz concert at the University Auditorium on the University of Florida campus.…
The Effects of Music on Athletic Performance
The Effects of Music on Athletic Performance. Introduction Have you ever seen anyone running outside without headphones? It is commonly agreed upon that music affects our physical abilities in many ways. However, most people don't understand the reasons behind these effects. The majority of people would usually try anything to improve their.…
Writing about Music A Guide to Writing in A & I 24
Music’s meaning. So in many respects, strong essays about music are like the best essays about anything. They have a plausible and interesting main argument, a co-herent structure, convincing evidence, and an elegant style. The best papers about music also feature a unique combination of precise attention to musical detail and…
Jazz Concert Reflection Essay Example
Check out our essay example on Jazz Concert Reflection to start writing. It was a new style of music that brought together music traditions from West Africa and.…
Music in Our Lives, an essay fiction FictionPress
Playing an instrument or even listen to music can help students retain information and be more successful in school. CONCLUSION. Music has been with us thought our long history, and will remain embedded in our cultural. It's a fine art used to express ourselves. It can move and influence our emotions in ways we don't even realize.…