Does God Exist Essay

Does God Exist Essay-57
There is, of course, this difference: whereas the concept of a bachelor explicitly contains the proposition that bachelors are unmarried, the concept of God does not explicitly contain any proposition asserting the existence of such a being.Even so, the basic idea is the same: ontological arguments attempt to show that we can deduce God's existence from, so to speak, the very definition of God.

Indeed, if the ontological arguments succeed, it is as much a contradiction to suppose that God doesn't exist as it is to suppose that there are square circles or female bachelors.As the objection is sometimes put, Anselm simply defines things into existence-and this cannot be done.Gaunilo shared this worry, believing that one could use Anselm's argument to show the existence of all kinds of non-existent things: Now if some one should tell me that there is …And since it is more excellent not to be in the understanding alone, but to exist both in the understanding and in reality, for this reason it must exist.For if it does not exist, any land which really exists will be more excellent than it; and so the island understood by you to be more excellent will not be more excellent." Gaunilo's argument, thus, proceeds by attempting to use Anselm's strategy to deduce the existence of a perfect island, which Gaunilo rightly views as a counterexample to the argument form.Likewise, cosmological arguments depend on certain empirical claims about the explanation for the occurrence of empirical events.In contrast, the ontological arguments are conceptual in roughly the following sense: just as the propositions constituting the concept of a bachelor imply that every bachelor is male, the propositions constituting the concept of God, according to the ontological argument, imply that God exists.Thus, on this general line of argument, it is a necessary truth that such a being exists; and this being is the God of traditional Western theism.This article explains and evaluates classic and contemporary versions of the ontological argument.I need to go out into the world and conduct some sort of empirical investigation using my senses.Likewise, if I want to prove that bachelors, unicorns, or viruses don't exist, I must do the same.


Comments Does God Exist Essay

The Latest from ©